This is getting completely insane. Both Romney and Obama are behaving badly and the analysis of these events on both sides is way off.
First, sure it's great that Osama Bin Laden is dead. We all give credit to Obama when having been presented with credible, although not certain, intelligence that Bin Laden was in Abbottabad, he approved a mission to have him killed. The only reason Obama is given so much credit is because of what happened on April 24, 1980. Had Operation Eagle Claw (Desert 1) succeeded and Jimmy Carter not been thoroughly humiliated by the perception of a continuing inability to project American power, we wouldn't really know the risks Obama would have faced had the Bid Laden raid failed and therefore the credit he's received for making a tough decision not been so heaped.
Obama handled himself well the night of the announcement. I thought the visit to the WTC was unnecessary pomp, however solemn. But now we have this Obama campaign ad. Contrary to the popular view from both the left and right, I think this ad and its repeated free media airings, will backfire. He already has a reputation as a self-promoting guy with few accomplishments. I think the American people will find this ad unseemly, even without the cheap shot at Romney. However glad we all are he's dead, it's simply not in the American character to celebrate the anniversary of someone's death. We don't dance in the streets rejoicing at someone's death: that is something Muslim countries do, not us.
Is April 30th an American holiday? No foreigner's death meant more in American history than Adolf Hitler's. But it was greeted at the time with sadness - for what he had put the world through - and intense relief. But we didn't hold celebrations or remembrances in 1946 on that date and we never have since.
This was, and is, all cheap political theatre. Obama made a call to proceed, that's why he's the Commander in Chief. FDR, Lincoln, Truman, et al. sent way more than two dozen men into perilous missions. George H.W. Bush not only ordered 500,000 boys into war, he organized a nearly unprecedented diplomatic and military coalition. That effort required monstrous skill and finesse. And he lost!!
I remember 1992. Bush made ads touting the nation's victory in expelling Iraq from Kuwait. But the credit was implied - a masterful job, guess who gets the credit? His ads also focused on the troops, not himself. He certainly questioned Clinton's foreign policy credentials. He even hinted he was a commie pinko for dodging the draft and protesting the war. But you never saw an ad that explicitly questioned whether Bill Clinton wouldn't have either the conviction or the ability to launch the first Gulf War. The only proper place for that Obama ad, minus the Romney dig, is at the conventon this summer in Obama's bio piece before the delegates.
Obama makes this ad because this is really all he has. No president with a real record of accomplishment would ever, ever produce an ad like that. And certainly not on the anniversary of someone's death. I won't even mention the outrageous hypocrisy of Team Obama making this ad after they took extreme umbrage at an almost identical Clinton ad aired during their primary fight in 2008. The Obama ad seriously diminishes the accomplishment itself. And that is how I believe Americans will perceive it. Watch the polling that will come out soon on the public's reaction to this ad.
As for Romney's response, my God, how stupid are these Bush advisors he surrounds himself with. He is making an entire day tomorrow in NYC celebrating Obama's success. How on Earth does that make any sense? Obama deflects and Romney obliges.
Sure, it's fine at some point during the campaign to do the whole NYC visit thing complete with a Rudy-9/11 theme including cops and firemen. But to do it tomorrow with Rudy is just cringeworthy. He really thinks in 2012 just standing next to Rudy Giuliani immunizes him from the Obama slander (put aside the fact that Rudy took Obama's position on the OBL hunt back in 2007 and that he openly hates Romney)? When the entire press corps - minus Fox News - is doing everything they can to bolster Obama and this anniversary, why would Romney help them? Just give the day to Obama and let the liberal press corps give him the over-sized credit he's receiving. Then move on and talk about the fucking economic mire we're in! Message, message, message!
{Addendum: Eric Fehrnstrom is the poster child for everything wrong with Mitt Romney and his campaign. It is bad enough that Romney went on a radio show a few weeks back and told a joke about his father laying off hundreds of auto workers. But you expect your advisors not to make these mistakes. So Fehrnstrom is at a roundtable discussion and is asked to give an example of Mitt Romney's humor. Perfect opportunity to humanize the man and make him relatable. Fehrnstrom then proceeds to tell a joke that involves Romney firing someone. In this case a "chambermaid." She wasn't actually fired, but her firing was the crux of Romney's joke. It's just unbelievable how Mitt Romney thinks his staff can compete with the ruthless Obama folks. The shake-up in that campaign is now long overdue for the big event.}
Update: Really, a secret visit to Afghanitan on the OBL anniversary? This little campaign stunt will wind up costing the taxpayers probably $50 million. Just as George W. Bush used to conflate the war in Iraq with 9/11, so too Obama seems determined to confuse Bin Laden's death and the so-called "War on Terror" with the decade-long war in Afghanistan. Bin laden's death, if strategically significant at all by 2011, was about the "War on Terror" and Al Queda's ability to attack the U.S. or U.S. interests. They were finished in Afghanistan. Afghanistan has become a war with a totally different mission then when we invaded in 2001. Our goal then was to get Al Queda and remove their bases and Afghanistan as a base. It was never to kill every last Taliban sympathizer in the country. However, that's what the war is about in 2012.
But after 9/11, the invasion of Afghanistan and then Iraq, the American people have stopped understanding what of this is interconnected and what isn't. And that's just how the White House, the Obama campaign, the Dept. of Homeland Security, the NSA, the TSA and the fawning news media like it.
I will give credit where credit is due though. As bad a president as Obamas has been, he's always been a pretty good campaigner. You have to just wince at how small and pathetic Romney and Rudy look handing out pizzas in Lower Manhattan while the Commander in Chief is signing agreements halfway around the world. Score the day big time for Team Obama over the always one step behind Team Romney.
Russell Harding